2 Rumsen Trace, Carmel
Santa Lucia Preserve Real Estate | Carmel Homes & Homesites
The Santa Lucia Preserve is unlike almost any other residential community on the Monterey Peninsula. Set within approximately 20,000 acres of the Santa Lucia Mountains near Carmel and Carmel Valley, The Preserve combines a limited collection of custom residences and homesites with one of California's most ambitious private-land conservation models.
Approximately 18,000 acres—90% of the Preserve—are permanently protected. Residential development, roads and private recreational amenities are concentrated within the remaining portion of the landscape, and only 297 homesites were created across the entire Preserve.
For buyers, ownership here is about considerably more than acreage. A Preserve property combines a defined residential building area with a much larger protected landscape, specialized community infrastructure, conservation responsibilities and optional access to an extensive private-club lifestyle.
View Current Santa Lucia Preserve Homes & Homesites ↓
Explore Carmel Valley Neighborhoods & Communities
Related Carmel Valley Searches
Related Carmel Real Estate
Is The Santa Lucia Preserve in Carmel or Carmel Valley?
The Preserve is another community where the mailing address and the way buyers experience the property can seem to point in different directions.
Santa Lucia Preserve properties use Carmel, CA 93923 addresses. The Preserve's primary Gatehouse is located at 1 Rancho San Carlos Road, Carmel, and is reached by traveling east from Highway 1 on Carmel Valley Road.
The community is outside incorporated Carmel-by-the-Sea and lies within unincorporated Monterey County. Its enormous 20,000-acre landscape extends through the Santa Lucia Mountains immediately inland from Carmel and alongside Carmel Valley.
For real estate purposes, The Preserve therefore belongs naturally in both the greater Carmel luxury market and the Carmel Valley estate-property market.
Buyers searching “Carmel homes” may encounter Preserve listings because of the Carmel 93923 address. Buyers searching Carmel Valley often consider the same properties because of the community's Carmel Valley Road access, inland climate, acreage, equestrian lifestyle and mountain setting.
Rather than creating two competing Santa Lucia Preserve pages, this website maintains one comprehensive guide and links to it from both our Carmel Real Estate and Carmel Valley Real Estate sections.
What Is The Santa Lucia Preserve?
The Santa Lucia Preserve is a private residential, conservation and recreational community occupying approximately 20,000 acres of the Santa Lucia Mountains.
Unlike a conventional gated subdivision where most of the land is divided into residential lots, The Preserve was planned so that approximately 90%—about 18,000 acres—is permanently protected.
The remaining land accommodates infrastructure, private club facilities and only 297 residential homesites.
The result is a residential environment where homes are intentionally dispersed within a much larger natural landscape of oak woodland, grasslands, ridges, streams and mountain terrain.
How the Santa Lucia Preserve Conservation Model Works
The conservation structure is one of the most important things a buyer should understand before purchasing in The Preserve.
A Preserve property can contain substantial gross acreage, but that does not mean all of that land can be developed.
Residential construction is concentrated within specifically designated development areas, often referred to as building envelopes or Homeland areas, while other portions of the property can be subject to conservation easements and stewardship requirements.
The Santa Lucia Conservancy works with owners to protect and manage the ecological resources of the permanently protected landscape.
This is why a Preserve homesite should never be valued simply on an acreage-per-dollar basis. The configuration and quality of the building envelope can be considerably more important than the property's total acreage.
Santa Lucia Preserve Homes
Completed Preserve residences are individually designed custom homes rather than standardized subdivision models.
Architecture can include:
- California ranch influences
- Contemporary mountain design
- Modern organic architecture
- Spanish and Mediterranean influences
- Highly site-specific custom estates
Successful Preserve homes typically emphasize their relationship with the landscape through thoughtful orientation, natural materials, substantial glazing and indoor-outdoor living.
Value can be influenced by:
- Architecture and construction quality
- Homesite location
- Mountain and valley views
- Privacy
- Building-envelope size
- Guest accommodations
- Equestrian improvements
- Pools and outdoor living areas
- Proximity to community amenities
- Internal drive time
- Condition and age of improvements
Santa Lucia Preserve Homesites
The Preserve contains some of the Monterey Peninsula's most unusual custom-home opportunities.
Homesites may occupy oak savannas, wooded settings, open meadows, mountain slopes and elevated ridges.
The development area is carefully located to preserve privacy and minimize the impact of residential construction on the surrounding landscape.
Before purchasing a homesite, buyers should investigate:
- Exact building-envelope location
- Building-envelope size
- Views and orientation
- Topography
- Architectural requirements
- Allowed accessory improvements
- Equestrian designation where applicable
- Utility infrastructure
- Driveway and construction access
- Conservation restrictions
- Fuel-management obligations
- Site-development costs
It is entirely possible for a Preserve property to contain dozens of acres while having a development envelope of only a small fraction of the total parcel.
The Ranch Club & Preserve Lifestyle
Private club membership can provide access to an unusually broad range of recreation within The Preserve.
Depending on membership, amenities and activities can include:
- Equestrian Center
- Nearly 100 miles of hiking, biking and riding trails
- Sports and fitness facilities
- Swimming pools
- Tennis
- Pickleball
- Bocce
- Dining
- Lodging
- Moore's Lake
- Fishing
- Paddle sports
- Community activities and events
The equestrian component is particularly significant for Carmel and Carmel Valley buyers who want both acreage-oriented living and access to organized horse facilities and trail systems.
The Preserve Golf Club
The Preserve Golf Club features an 18-hole championship course designed by Tom Fazio within the Santa Lucia landscape.
The planning philosophy is very different from a traditional golf subdivision. Houses do not line every fairway, and the course remains visually integrated with the broader natural landscape.
Golf Club membership is separate from real estate ownership and is subject to the club's current application, approval, invitation, fees and membership requirements.
Club Membership Is Separate From Real Estate Ownership
Purchasing a Santa Lucia Preserve home or homesite does not automatically convey all recreational privileges.
The Preserve offers multiple club membership opportunities, and membership is subject to separate application and approval.
Buyers should verify:
- Which memberships are currently available
- Eligibility
- Application and approval requirements
- Initiation fees
- Ongoing dues
- Transfer provisions
- Which amenities each membership includes
This should be investigated independently from the real estate transaction.
Santa Lucia Community Services District
The Preserve differs substantially from independent rural acreage because it has organized community infrastructure administered by the Santa Lucia Community Services District.
The District provides or manages important services that include:
- Potable water
- Wastewater systems
- Road maintenance
- Storm drainage
- Solid-waste services
- Security and gate operations
- Broadband infrastructure
- Emergency-response functions
- Other community infrastructure
Buyers should review current District assessments, service charges, budgets and property-specific obligations during due diligence.
Wildfire Preparedness & Emergency Services
Wildfire is an important consideration for any property in the Santa Lucia Mountains.
The Preserve has organized fire and emergency-response infrastructure, including cooperation with the Monterey County Regional Fire District and on-site emergency capabilities.
That infrastructure does not eliminate wildfire or insurance risk.
Buyers should still investigate:
- Homeowners insurance availability
- Wildfire coverage
- Construction materials
- Defensible space
- Fuel-management requirements
- Access and evacuation considerations
- The specific property's risk characteristics
Roads, Travel Time & Privacy
The Santa Lucia Preserve covers approximately 31 square miles and contains more than 40 miles of private roadway.
That scale matters.
A property relatively close to the Gatehouse can create a very different daily routine from a homesite located deep within The Preserve.
For buyers prioritizing maximum privacy, that additional drive can be part of the appeal.
For buyers who expect to travel to Carmel, Monterey, schools, medical appointments or Highway 1 several times each day, internal drive time should be evaluated carefully.
We strongly recommend driving from any property being considered to the Gatehouse and the community amenities that will be used regularly.
Connectivity & Resident Services
Despite its rural character, The Preserve has extensive underground high-speed fiber infrastructure.
This can be particularly important to owners who work remotely or use a Preserve estate for extended periods rather than simply as an occasional retreat.
The community also provides Resident Services that can assist owners with property and household needs, a meaningful feature for second-home ownership.
Santa Lucia Preserve vs. Teháma
Luxury buyers often compare The Preserve with nearby Teháma.
Santa Lucia Preserve
- Approximately 20,000 acres
- 297 homesites
- Carmel 93923 mailing address
- Approximately 90% permanently protected
- Large-scale conservation model
- Nearly 100 miles of trails
- Major equestrian component
- Ranch Club and Golf Club membership opportunities
- Community Services District infrastructure
- Extraordinary physical scale and privacy
Teháma
- Nearly 2,000 acres
- Only 90 homesites
- Carmel 93923 mailing address
- Located within the Carmel Valley Master Plan
- More compact private-estate environment
- Closer relationship with Carmel and Monterey
- Custom estates and homesites
- Social and fitness amenities
- Invitation-only golf membership
- Ocean, bay, valley and mountain-view opportunities
Both communities can deliver extraordinary privacy.
The primary difference is scale. Teháma functions more like an exceptionally low-density private estate community, while The Preserve places owners within a vast conservation and recreational landscape.
Santa Lucia Preserve vs. Independent Carmel Valley Acreage
Buyers seeking substantial land frequently compare The Preserve with Cachagua and Upper Carmel Valley or other Carmel Valley ranch and acreage properties.
The ownership structures can be dramatically different.
Santa Lucia Preserve
- Controlled-access private community
- Community-maintained road system
- Organized water and wastewater infrastructure
- Security
- Conservation easements
- Architectural controls
- Private recreational membership opportunities
- Community Services District
Independent Carmel Valley Acreage
- Independent rural parcels
- More varied private-road arrangements
- Wells and septic systems are common
- Less standardized infrastructure
- Different land-use and zoning conditions
- No Preserve-wide conservation or club structure
The choice frequently comes down to whether the buyer wants greater independence or the infrastructure, recreation and conservation structure of a highly organized private community.
What Buyers Should Investigate Before Purchasing in The Preserve
Jurisdiction
The Santa Lucia Preserve uses Carmel 93923 addresses but is not located within incorporated Carmel-by-the-Sea. It lies in unincorporated Monterey County.
Conservation & Openlands
Understand which portions of the property can be improved and which are protected by conservation easements or stewardship requirements.
Building Envelope
For vacant homesites, verify whether the planned residence, guest accommodations, pool, barn and other improvements will fit within the designated development area.
Community Services District Costs
Review current assessments, service charges and property-specific obligations associated with the Santa Lucia Community Services District.
Club Membership
Verify current Ranch Club and Golf Club opportunities, application requirements, initiation costs, dues and transfer provisions separately from the real estate purchase.
Insurance
Investigate homeowners and wildfire insurance early in the purchase process.
Internal Drive Time
Drive from the actual property to the Gatehouse, Hacienda, Golf Club and other amenities you expect to use regularly.
Construction Costs
For vacant land, include site work, infrastructure, architectural requirements and specialized construction logistics when estimating the complete project cost.
Frequently Asked Questions About Santa Lucia Preserve Real Estate
Is The Santa Lucia Preserve in Carmel or Carmel Valley?
The Preserve uses Carmel, CA 93923 addresses and its Gatehouse is accessed from Carmel Valley Road. It is outside incorporated Carmel-by-the-Sea and lies in unincorporated Monterey County. Buyers commonly consider The Preserve as part of both the greater Carmel luxury market and the Carmel Valley estate-property market.
Is The Santa Lucia Preserve part of Carmel-by-the-Sea?
No. Although Preserve properties use Carmel mailing addresses, the community is outside the incorporated City of Carmel-by-the-Sea.
How large is The Santa Lucia Preserve?
The Preserve encompasses approximately 20,000 acres in the Santa Lucia Mountains near Carmel and Carmel Valley.
How many homesites are in The Santa Lucia Preserve?
The community is limited to 297 residential homesites across its approximately 20,000-acre landscape.
How much of The Santa Lucia Preserve is protected?
Approximately 18,000 acres, representing about 90% of The Preserve, are permanently protected.
Can you buy both homes and vacant land in The Santa Lucia Preserve?
Yes. Depending on available inventory, buyers may encounter completed custom residences as well as undeveloped homesites.
Does purchasing a Preserve property include Golf Club membership?
No. Club memberships are separate from the purchase of real estate and are subject to their own application, approval, fees and membership requirements.
Does The Santa Lucia Preserve have equestrian facilities?
Yes. The Preserve includes an Equestrian Center and an extensive private trail system that supports riding and other outdoor recreation.
Who maintains the roads and utilities in The Santa Lucia Preserve?
The Santa Lucia Community Services District provides or manages important community infrastructure including roads, potable water, wastewater, drainage, solid-waste services, security, broadband and emergency-response functions.
What is a Preserve building envelope?
The building envelope is the designated development area where residential structures and related improvements may be permitted. A property's total acreage can be much larger than its actual development area.
Is The Santa Lucia Preserve the same as Teháma?
No. They are separate communities. The Preserve encompasses approximately 20,000 acres with 297 homesites and an extensive conservation model, while Teháma encompasses nearly 2,000 acres with only 90 homesites and is located within the Carmel Valley Master Plan.
What should I investigate before buying a Preserve homesite?
Important considerations include the building envelope, conservation restrictions, design-review requirements, site-development costs, Community Services District obligations, club membership opportunities, insurance, infrastructure, internal travel time and the feasibility of the residence and accessory improvements you plan to build.
Buying or Selling Santa Lucia Preserve Real Estate
The Santa Lucia Preserve is a highly specialized real estate market where gross acreage alone tells very little about value. Building envelopes, conservation land, architecture, views, equestrian status, internal location, community obligations and proximity to amenities can materially affect one property relative to another.
If you are considering buying or selling a home or homesite in The Preserve, call Mark Bruno and the Monterey Peninsula Home Team at (831) 917-8190. We can help you evaluate available properties, compare The Preserve with Teháma and other Carmel and Carmel Valley estate properties, and identify the property-specific issues that matter before making a decision.
Browse current Santa Lucia Preserve homes and homesites for sale below. Because the community contains a limited number of residences and homesites, available inventory can vary substantially throughout the year.
Current Santa Lucia Preserve Homes & Homesites
Based on information from MLSListings MLS as of All data, including all measurements and calculations of area, is obtained from various sources and has not been, and will not be, verified by broker or MLS. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
Copyright 2026 MLSListings Inc. All rights reserved